FP911 Login or Register Today
Sign up for the

FantasyPros911

Newsletter Today


For Email Marketing you can trust

Follow FantasyPros911 Here

FaceBook MySpace Twitter YouTube All Articles RSS Feed
Bookmark and Share
Error
  • XML Parsing Error at 1:23. Error 73: > required
Top 10 Worst Number One Overall Picks in the MLB Draft PDF Print E-mail
FP911's Top Ten
Written by Brian Joura   
Sunday, 31 May 2009 10:40

The MLB Draft is just over a week away and the foregone conclusion is that the Nationals will use the first overall pick on Stephen Strasburg. Most years, there is a consensus top overall pick so one might think that with the 44 years of the draft that we had several Hall of Famers go as the first overall pick. But until Ken Griffey Jr. and Chipper Jones retire and wait five years, we will not have one single guy with that distinction. 

 

On the other side of the coin, some people think that the first overall pick has turned out to be a bust just as often as not. But is it fair to consider someone like Tim Foli or Bill Almon, who played 15 and 16 years in the majors, respectively, busts? Teams usually end up getting a solid major league player at the top slot of the draft, even if they do not always end up taking the best player. 

But there have been some busts. So, here are the Top 10 Worst Number One Overall Picks in the MLB Draft. 

10. Paul Wilson
 

Wilson went 13-5 with a 2.08 ERA in 143.0 innings pitched in his junior season at Florida State, with 32 walks and 161 strikeouts. He was a no-brainer selection as the top pick in the 1994 draft. That was the year the Mets had eight of the first 98 picks and the closest to an impact player they got was the oft-injured Jay Payton. Meanwhile, Wilson was also dogged by shoulder and elbow injuries that robbed him of most of his career. In parts of seven seasons in the majors, Wilson went 40-58 with a 4.86 ERA

 

Best first-round picks that season: Nomar Garciaparra (12th), Paul Konerko (13th), Jason Varitek (14th).

 
9. Matt Anderson
 

Anderson could throw 100 mph and looked like he was going to be a dominating closer for the Tigers, who took him leading off the 1997 draft. He had 22 saves in 2001 and what should have been the start of a nice run ended in the oddest of ways. Anderson ended up tearing a muscle in his throwing arm when he participated in an octopus throwing contest at Comerica Park. He ended up with a final line of 15-7 with 26 saves in seven seasons. 

Best first-round picks that season: Lance Berkman (16th), Troy Glaus (3rd), J.D. Drew (2nd).

 
8. Shawn Abner
 

If you ask most people about amateur baseball in 1984, most will talk about the U.S. Olympic team. Generally considered the finest amateur team ever, it consisted of 18 first-round picks. However, with the first overall pick, instead of taking a college player, the Mets selected H.S. outfielder Abner when they could not come to a pre-draft deal with Mark McGwire. Abner played parts of six years in the majors after being traded to the Padres in the Kevin McReynolds deal. Abner finished with a lifetime .227 average and a .591 OPS in 902 career plate appearances. 

Best first-round picks that season: Mark McGwire (10th), Jay Bell (8th), Billy Swift (2nd).

 
7. Danny Goodwin
 

In 1971, the White Sox took high school catcher Goodwin as the top overall pick. He elected to go to college at Southern University after feeling that Chicago’s offer of $60,000 was not worth forsaking college. In 1975, Goodwin was again the top overall pick, this time by the Angels. Goodwin hit in college and hit in the minors. But he never hit in the pros. Also, he hurt his arm and had to move from catcher to first base, further hurting his prospects. Goodwin played seven years in the majors and finished with a .236 average before ending his career overseas in Japan.

 

Best first-round picks that season: Rick Cerone (7th), Dale Berra (20th), Clint Hurdle (9th).

 
6. Bryan Bullington
 

As teams worried about being able to afford top draft picks, a new word entered the baseball vocabularly – signability. The Pirates made Bullington the top overall pick in the 2002 draft (the infamous “Moneyball Draft”) where the consensus at the time was there was no “can’t miss” talent. However,in hindsight the 2002 Draft was loaded with star players. Bullington was simply a signability pick. Dave Littlefield, the team’s own general manager, declared Bullington, “a good #3 pitcher.” To make matters worse, Bullington suffered shoulder problems. He has pitched parts of four seasons in the majors but is still active as a reliever with the Blue Jays. Bullington currently sits with an 0-5 record with a 5.08 ERA in 13 games. 

Best first-round picks that season: Zack Greinke (6th), Cole Hamels (17th), Prince Fielder (7th).

 
5. Al Chambers
 

The Mariners agreed to a pre-draft deal with 1979 top pick Al Chambers for the same $60,000 that Danny Goodwin found unacceptable eight years earlier. Perhaps that should have been a sign. Chambers was supposed to be a cross between Dave Parker and Dave Winfield with off-the-charts power. But while he hit for good averages in the minors, he never showed that awesome power. Chambers reached the majors as a 22-year-old in 1983, but played only 57 games in parts of three seasons, amassing just two home runs and a .208 average in 120 at-bats. 

Best first-round picks that season: Andy Van Slyke (6th), Tim Wallach (10th), Steve Howe (16th).

 
4. David Clyde
 

All of the players on this list have a sad story. But hands down the saddest story was that of Clyde. In his senior year in high school, he went 18-0 with 14 shutouts and he established a high school record with 328 strikeouts. He was the first HS pitcher drafted with the first overall pick when the Rangers took him in 1973. Just 19 days after graduating high school, he was pitching in the majors. Clyde won his first start, became a gate attraction for the struggling Rangers (just two years after the move from Washington) and Texas kept him in the majors even though he was not ready. The following year, Billy Martin replaced Whitey Herzog as the team’s manager and he thought Clyde belonged in the minors. When the front office refused to ship him out, Clyde went 31 days without not only pitching in a game, but even warming up on the sidelines. Clyde lost his curveball, ended up having two shoulder surgeries and had problems with alcohol. He finished his career in the majors with an 18-33 mark with a 4.63 ERA. 

Best first-round picks that season: Robin Yount (3rd), Dave Winfield (4th), Lee Mazzilli (14th).

 
3. Brien Taylor
 

There is an old baseball saying about the pitcher with the million dollar arm and the 10 cent head. Brien Taylor came from humble beginnings in the coastal town of Beaufort, North Carolina. But he had an electric arm, was clocked at 99 in a high school game and signed a $1.2 million deal with the Yankees as the top overall pick in the 1991 draft. Two years later he went 13-7 in Double-A and was on the cusp of stardom. But he got into a fight after his older brother got roughed up and wrecked his shoulder. There are numerous accounts of how everything went down that fateful night. But the only thing that really matters is that Taylor needed surgery, with Dr. Frank Jobe calling it one of the worst injuries he had seen up to that point. After the surgery both his fastball and command deserted him and Taylor never pitched in the majors. 

Best first-round picks that season: Manny Ramirez (13th), Shawn Green (16th), Cliff Floyd (14th).

 
2. Steve Chilcott
 

In the second year of the MLB Draft, there was no precedent against drafting high school catchers. In 1966 Steve Chilcott became one of the poster boys for that cause as the Mets took him over Reggie Jackson with the top overall pick. It sounds ridiculous now, but both players were ranked 1-2 on nearly every team’s draft board. The Mets sent Casey Stengel to scout Chilcott and he went 4-4 with Stengel in attendance. With the Mets without a legitimate catching prospect anywhere in the farm system, Chilcott was the pick. He signed for a $75,000 bonus. Chilcott never made the majors, played seven injury-plagued seasons in the minors and was released by the Yankees in 1972 after just 331 career games. 

Best first-round picks that season: Reggie Jackson (2nd), Gary Nolan (13th), Richie Hebner (15th).

 
1. Matt Bush
 

With Chilcott, many teams thought he was the best player. But with Bush in 2004, no one thought that. He was considered a good player but was basically a signability pick, chosen by the Padres at least as much for his San Diego roots as his baseball ability. Still, he received a hefty $3,150,000 bonus. Bush was suspended by the Padres before he even played a game for an altercation outside a club. He hit poorly for two seasons, broke an ankle, converted to pitching, injured his elbow, got into alcohol-related trouble, was dealt to Toronto and finally was released this year before the season for violating the Blue Jays’ zero tolerance behavior policy. 

Best first-round picks that season: Justin Verlander (2nd), Jered Weaver (12th), Stephen Drew (15th). 

Background information for many players in this article was taken from Baseball America’s The Baseball Draft: The First 25 Years: 1965-1989. 

 

After Strasburg, who do you think is the best player available in the 2009 Draft?

Trackback(0)
Comments (45)Add Comment
Basket Nike Pas cher
written by Basket Nike Pas cher, August 31, 2010
thanks for sharing this
nike shox
written by nike shox shoes, August 28, 2010
You ought to seriously think about working on growing this blog into a dominant voice in this niche. You clearly have a grasp grasp of the topics everyone is browsing for on this site anyways and you could maybe even make a buck or three off of some offers. I would dive into following recent headlines and increasing the number of articles you make and I guarantee you’d begin earning some easy traffic soon. Just a brainstorm, good luck in whatever you do!
about jordan shoes
written by jordan retro, August 27, 2010
Timberland Outlet
Vibram Five Fingers Sale
Vibram Five Fingers Outlet
Vibram Outlet
Shoes Outlet
Mbt Outlet
Air Jordan Store
Jordan Shop
Air Jordan Store
Nike Outlet
Nike Store
Nike Store
Nike Shox Sale
Gucci Store
UGG Boots Store
UGG Boots Outlet
UGG Boots sale
Cheap UGG Boots
nike shox
written by nikeshox, August 25, 2010
It most likely you didn’t get a proper nike shox, and your feet get painful. You are likely to search a pair of proper cheap nike shox shoes if you come to our site. A new wholesale nike shox r4 if you like. Certainly, if you don’t want it ,you can select another kinds, such as nike shox nz and so on.
nike shox
written by nikeshox, August 25, 2010
Are you eagerly to have a nike shox shoes? Then you can’t miss and must come to our discount nike shox quickly. Here you will find every kinds of shoes you need, which includes nike shox nz and nike shox r4.We have the lowest price and they are all cheap nike shox shoes, Come on now!
...
written by Nike shox, August 17, 2010

We could enjoy best cheap cheap nike shoes sales online,about all kinds of nike air max,nike air max 90,nike shox.Run retailing and wholesale trade worldwidely for years,free shipping, super sale off retailing with 1 week delivery to your door.
...
written by Nike Rifts , August 16, 2010
i think the product is so good ! Dont miss it ! come and buy one for yourself !
http://www.lovemypursemall.com/
written by gucci, August 10, 2010
Thanks for sharing!
cool electronic gadgets
written by cool electronic gadgets, July 26, 2010
definitely trey griffey
hype
written by maria, July 15, 2010
drafts are just media hype and a lot of marketing. the amateur league is far more different than the pros. unless these rookies find a good link building service to bridge the gap of the pressure playing in the big league, then picks are just numbers.
...
written by cheap uggs uk, July 11, 2010
When tomorrow turns in today, yesterday, and someday that no more important in your memory, we suddenly realize that we r pushed forward by time. This is not a train in still in which you may feel for ward when another train goes by. It is the truth that we've all grown up.And we become different.  
Good article
written by jennifer, July 08, 2010
Thank you for your hard work
http://www.cheap-shoesonline.com cheap shoes online cheap ed hardy
written by Gucci outlet, July 05, 2010

Good study day day up
How long does it take you to commute every day?
The commuters in the big cities suffer a lot from the congestion and transfer of bus and subway every day.
When they finally reach the company, they will then rush into the crowded elevators.
It is like a battle, which is indescribable. The survey reveals that only 30% of the commuters in major cities, such as Shanghai spend less than an hour on their way to work.
It wastes tremendous effort to take several hours on their way from home to company.
Who knows how to buy gucci online,that is may question.
air jordans
written by nike air jordan, July 04, 2010
Secretary of the Interior issued a statement immediately nike air jordan Salazar responded that he signed in the next few days, nike jordan shoes a new deep-water oil drilling ban in order to eliminate all walks of life a period of 6 months drilling ban "is necessary air jordans shoes or appropriate, whether the Government's purview all doubt. " Salazar said in a statement, jordans shoes as the BP oil spill accidents, the Home Office every day was clear evidence air jordan 2010 of the need to suspend the deep-water oil drilling. Moreover,cheap jordan shoes the British oil companies still can not stop the oil leak, air jordans it makes it even more conclusive evidence. Salazar also said the United States Department of Justice will award 22 Feldman appeal. White House spokesman Robert Gibbs made the day after the ruling, said the U.S. government will immediately appeal this.
savbsdvb
written by asgfvsgbv, June 18, 2010
christian louboutin
louboutin
christian louboutin shoes
christian louboutin sale
christian louboutin discount
christian louboutin
louboutin
louboutin shoes
louboutin sale
christian louboutin discount
Vibram FiveFingers
Vibram Five Fingers
FiveFingers
Five Fingers
Five Finger shoes
jimmy choo sale
jimmy choo
jimmy choo shoes
jimmy choo pumps
jimmy choo discount
herve leger
herve leger clothing
herve leger dress
herve leger wedding dress
herve leger dress sale
manolo blahnik
manolo blahnik shoes
manolo blahnik discount
manolo blahnik sale
manolo blahnik ebay
canada goose
canada goose sale
canada goose coats
canada goose jackets
canada goose outerwear

christian louboutin
chanel
herve leger
vibram five fingers
canada goose parka
moncler jackets
christian louboutin boots
christian louboutin pumps
christian louboutin sandals
christian louboutin evening
christian louboutin wedding
manolo blahnik shoes
manolo blahnik boots
manolo blahnik wedding
tory burch
alexander mcqueen
chanel
giuseppe zanotti
jimmy choo
salvatore ferragamo
yves saint laurent
vibram five fingers
miu miu
chloe
rene caovilla
lanvin shoes
vibram five fingers kso
vibram five fingers classic
vibram five fingers sprint
christian louboutin boots
christian louboutin pumps
christian louboutin sandals
christian louboutin evening
christian louboutin wedding
manolo blahnik shoes
manolo blahnik boots
manolo blahnik wedding
tory burch
alexander mcqueen
chanel
giuseppe zanotti
jimmy choo
salvatore ferragamo
yves saint laurent
vibram five fingers
miu miu
chloe
lanvin shoes
xcbvc
written by lastchaos gold, June 01, 2010
The second task last chaos gold is to ask you go to collect ten wizard powders, and you can get them lastchaos gold
wow
written by cocoyu, May 28, 2010
wedding invitations wedding invitations
full lace wigs full lace wigs
http://www.coachoutletmalls.com
written by coach outlet, May 28, 2010
A woman said to her husband, “dear, look at our sheet! It"s Coach outlet too dirty. Would you like to wash it now?”
The man looked at the sheet and then thought for a while and then said, “I don"t think it"s necessary. coach handbags
We can turn the sheet over. Is that all right?”
Cabal money
written by Cabal money, May 27, 2010
All gamers want to buy Cabal Online Alz to promote their character level easily, more Cabal money they own, more items they can buy in game.
http://www.gucci-zone.com
written by gucci bags, May 27, 2010
A lifeguard to visitors to protest: I notice you have three days, you gucci bags annot in urine wang swimming pool.
Wang: everybody in the swimming pool.
The lifeguard: yes! Sir, gucci outlet ut only if you stand on the board in the urine...
vcbvc
written by lastchaos gold , May 27, 2010
The second task last chaos gold is to ask you go to collect ten wizard powders, and you can get them lastchaos gold
http://www.coach-handbags-outlet.com
written by coach handbags outlet, May 26, 2010
Marriage is an umbrella. With it, when the storm, you will be comfortable ,but in some natural flatly light weather, coach handbags the more umbrella the unavoidable.
www.coachoutletfactory.com
written by coach outlet factory, May 24, 2010
A guy to Beijing to work, with a strength, when a milkman. Soon, he rely on coach factory outlet our own efforts, the company established the milkman. Because he is honest, quality, service, after several years of rapid development of his company to have 20 million subscribers.
reply this post
written by TrudyFoster, May 18, 2010
Specialists tell that loans help a lot of people to live the way they want, just because they are able to feel free to buy necessary stuff. Furthermore, different banks offer sba loan for different persons.
reply this post
written by SchultzMaude23, May 18, 2010
When you're in a not good position and have no cash to get out from that point, you will need to take the business loans. Because that should aid you for sure. I take car loan every time I need and feel myself good because of it.
http://www.cheap-shoesonline.c...22447.html MBT Shoes
written by MBT Shoes, May 16, 2010
other cheap nike max http://www.cheap-shoesonline.c...c-115.html goods.We are looking forward
nike air max http://www.cheap-shoesonline.c...c-115.html to building sincere and long-term business relationships with you.
http://www.cheap-shoesonline.c...22447.html MBT Shoes
written by MBT Shoes, May 16, 2010
There are several kinds of charming discount Air max wholesaling in our online
look
written by swb, May 14, 2010
There YSL Shoes
is Yves Saint Laurent Shoesno problem
look
written by swb, May 14, 2010
All Yves Saint Laurent Shoesthe YSL Shoestime, every one like you
...
written by 12312, April 28, 2010
...
written by nike shox sale, April 19, 2010
...
written by nike shox sale, April 19, 2010
...
written by nike shox sale, April 19, 2010
cheap nike shox
written by nike shox sale, April 19, 2010
Your site unique style of fashion and will always have fresh ad content. I am quite taken up with this author's style. I found a nike shox shop on the web and show great interset in nike shox r4 shoe. I bought a pair of nike shox r4 torch shoes with best quality and low price. The online shop’s main business is Nike shox shoes series ,You can buy all kind of cheap nike shox shoe here. most of the shoes are on sale now,40% discount, and shipping is free. they supply the best service.shipped out the order to your door within 5-7 business days.
Here’s the website: http://www.nikeshoxsales.com
afsdg
written by gdfg, April 16, 2010
You can even weak players in wow gold. Do not forget to what extent the popular stuff in the Auction House. The activity of the Chinese gold farmers, there is usually a kind of pattern.
...
written by last chaos gold, April 07, 2010
made by f0rest
...
written by wow cd key, April 07, 2010
made by fish
...
written by Aion kinah, April 07, 2010
made by ksharp
...
written by metin2 yang, April 07, 2010
made by owin
...
written by wow power leveling, April 07, 2010
made by owen
www.airmaxforsale.com
written by air jordan, February 25, 2010
 Jack feell off his bicycle and got hurt. A air jordan beautiful young nurse asked him to fill forms. Jack finished them and gave them back."Anything else?" The nurse asked. "Yes,"Jack thinks for a while and said,"I'm a bachelor."
air max for sale
...
written by gucci women shoes, December 14, 2009
Gucci handbags is a combination of exquisite workmanship and superb detailing with their perfect cut, stamped logos, locks, date codes and serial numbers. That is why Gucci handbags enjoy good reputation in the society.
...
written by Sarah, July 01, 2009
Addendum....
Matt Bush was arrested again, this time on June 28, 2009, after Police in the San Diego community of Mission Valley responded to a road rage call.
"He was taken to jail and booked on charges of assult, DUI, driving on a suspended license, vandalism and resisting arrest.
"The arrest comes just two weeks after Bush pleaded guilty to a drunken assault at Granite Hills High School in February."
...
written by thommy, June 01, 2009
definitely trey griffey. there is a history of baseball greatness in that family.
After Strasburg, who do you think is the best player available in the 2009 Draft?
written by MLBHomeRun.com, June 01, 2009
Dustin Ackley from UNC is the best position (1B/OF). Some see him being picked by the Mariners. Many consider him the safest pick as he posted a .410/.517/.757 this year with 35 extra-base hits and a 44-25 BB/K ratio.

Write comment

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy